Sally Field

Tova Sullivan

David Parent

Police Officer

Michael Delleva

Tanner

Duncan Fraser

Ex-Cop

Kareem Malcolm

Host

Andres Joseph

Brad

Katie Findlay

Liz

Arielle Tuliao

Field Trip Teacher

Sasha Williams

Mother

Michael Karl Richards

Will

Miles Marthaller

5/6 Year Old Erik

Meghan Heffern

Young Tova

Michael Adamthwaite

Fisherman

Alfred Molina

Marcellus (voice) (uncredited)

Chris William Martin

Simon Brinks

Shauna Johannesen

Eliza Wright

Lewis Pullman

Cameron Cassmore

Colm Meaney

Ethan Mack

Joan Chen

Janice Kim

Kathy Baker

Mary Ann Minetti